3B-7B local models — all 53 · V1

Local Model Testing · Tier v2.0

The second Sigma5C local-model observation. Forty-eight local models in the 3B–7B parameter range plus five cloud-routed models for calibration. Prompt difficulty was raised: binary-search and decorator coding tasks, an 8-ball weighing puzzle, MISSISSIPPI combinatorics, and a new Analysis category covering race conditions and complexity reasoning.
avg overall
6.91
local avg
6.70
cloud avg
8.92
cloud premium
+2.22
v1→v2 drop
-2.06

Harder prompts, an Analysis category, broader model lineup

Where v1.0 (sub-3B) had a flat ceiling effect — many models tying at 9.4 / 10 because the prompts were too easy — v2.0 introduces deliberately harder prompts and a new Analysis category. Score weights are rebalanced: Code 25%, Reasoning 20%, Instruction 15%, Math 15%, Analysis 15%, Summary 10%.

Of the nine models scored under both v1.0 and v2.0 prompts, the average drop was -2.06 points (v1.0 avg 9.36 → v2.0 avg 7.29). The largest single drop was phi3.5:latest at -2.51. This validates the v2.0 prompt design: harder prompts have separated the leaders from the followers.

Headline findings

#1 overall

qwen2.5:7b

9.71 / 10. Highest-scoring local model. Wins reasoning, instruction, summary, math, and analysis categories outright.

Cloud calibration

ministral-3:8b-cloud

9.61. Highest-scoring cloud-routed entry. Tier-A wraparound — close to qwen2.5:7b despite being remote.

Surprise small

granite4:3b

8.48 at 12.6 tok/s. Strong perf-per-byte. Fastest local: granite3-moe:3b at 31.7 tok/s.

Hardest category: Analysis (avg 5.21 / 10). The new race-condition and complexity reasoning prompts separated the top tier (9+ on Analysis) from the rest. Easiest category: Instruction Following (avg 8.30 / 10).

The full 3B-7B observed score table

All 53 models ranked. Cloud-routed entries are denoted by -cloud in the model name; their tok/s appears as "cloud" since CPU-throughput is not applicable.
Overall
qwen2.5:7b
9.71
ministral-3:8b-cloud
9.61
gpt-oss:20b-cloud
9.4
exaone3.5:latest
8.89
qwen2.5-coder:7b
8.86
gemma3n:e4b
8.81
translategemma:4b
8.76
falcon3:7b
8.69
ministral-3:3b-cloud
8.68
gemma3:4b-cloud
8.63
ministral-3:3b
8.62
command-r7b:latest
8.59
granite4:3b
8.48
granite3.3:8b
8.46
rnj-1:8b-cloud
8.26
gemma3:4b
8.26
qwen2.5vl:7b
8.25
qwen2:7b
8.21
qwen2.5-coder-sigma5c:7b
8.19
cogito:3b
7.99
dolphin3:latest
7.92
huihui_ai/dolphin3-abliterated:8b
7.88
cogito:8b
7.81
granite4:latest
7.66
dolphin-2.9.2-qwen2-7b:Q3_K_M
7.63
qwen2-math:latest
7.54
phi4-mini:latest
7.44
qwen2.5:3b
7.43
phi3:latest
7.4
llama3.2:3b
7.4
falcon3:3b
7.36
qwen2.5-coder:3b
7.35
lfm2.5-thinking:latest
7.28
dolphin-mistral:latest
7.19
dolphin-llama3.1:latest
7.09
granite3.1-moe:3b
6.93
olmo2:7b
6.89
phi3.5:latest
6.66
hermes3:3b
6.6
codeqwen:latest
5.87
qwen:7b
5.49
granite3-moe:3b
5.46
qwen3-vl:4b
4.89
dolphin-2.9.2-qwen2-7b:Q2_K
4.53
deepseek-r1:7b
4.15
deepseek-r1:8b
4.01
qwen3:4b
3.8
deepscaler:latest
3.75
qwen:4b
3.26
openthinker:7b
2.2
smallthinker:3b
2.05
qwen3:8b
1.9
exaone-deep:7.8b
1.88

53 entries · ordered by Overall as observed in this run · not a ranking

Models

Families

Companies

Related observations

AI-generated & AI-scored. Every observation on this site is produced and judged by AI, and AI makes mistakes. Treat each result as a recorded observation under a declared protocol, as of its date. Method and marker legend